Share This Article
Standing at the sushi bar, the array of glistening fish can tempt even the most seasoned connoisseur. Among the salmon, tuna, and mackerel, there’s one white-fleshed fish that often piques curiosity—escolar. Sometimes labeled “white tuna” or “butterfish,” escolar’s creamy texture and mild flavor make it an alluring choice for diners seeking something new. Yet, beneath its inviting surface lies a story that combines culinary delight with controversy, health risks, and identity confusion.
Exploring “What is escolar in sushi?” takes us into the heart of sushi bar culture, food safety debates, and the evolving world of seafood authenticity. Understanding escolar is essential for those who seek to enjoy sushi responsibly—and with full knowledge of what’s on their plate.
What Exactly Is Escolar? Origins, Biology, and Identity
Escolar (Lepidocybium flavobrunneum) is a deep-sea fish found in tropical and temperate waters worldwide. A member of the Gempylidae family, its relatives include oilfish and snake mackerel. Escolar has a firm, oily, and buttery flesh—features that make it highly prized in both sashimi and nigiri presentations.
Escolar vs. “White Tuna”—A Naming Dilemma
In North America, escolar has frequently been mislabeled as “white tuna,” but it isn’t related to true tuna species. This labeling confusion isn’t just a trivial matter; a study conducted in the early 2010s by Oceana, a global ocean advocacy group, revealed that a significant share of “white tuna” sold in U.S. sushi restaurants was actually escolar.
This mislabeling can be partly attributed to escolar’s lower cost and similar appearance to albacore. While some sushi chefs choose to market the fish transparently, others may use alternative names such as “butterfish” or “oilfish,” further muddying the waters for uninitiated diners.
Taste, Texture, and Presentation at Sushi Bars
Escolar’s popularity at sushi bars largely stems from its luxurious texture and delicate flavor profile. The flesh is snow-white, with a rich, buttery mouthfeel often compared to fatty tuna (toro), making it especially appealing in raw preparations.
How Escolar Is Served
- Nigiri: Slices of escolar draped over vinegared rice.
- Sashimi: Thinly sliced, undressed fillets enjoyed for their texture.
- Rolls: Sometimes paired with spicy sauces or vegetables to complement its creaminess.
Beyond its taste, escolar’s visual appeal draws in adventurous eaters and first-timers alike. High-end sushi bars may label it clearly, while budget spots might substitute it for more expensive species.
Health and Safety: The Truth About Escolar’s Risks
Despite its inviting flavor, escolar presents unique health concerns. The fish is loaded with wax esters—indigestible fats that the human body cannot fully process. Consumption in significant quantities can lead to gastrointestinal discomfort, including a side effect infamously known as “keriorrhea,” or oily, orange diarrhea.
Anecdotal reports—and warnings from food safety authorities in Japan, Italy, and other nations—have prompted some countries to restrict or ban the sale of escolar. The U.S. FDA currently allows its sale but recommends clear labeling and consumer education.
“Escolar’s oily flesh is unique in the seafood world, but its wax ester content means diners should exercise moderation. Even small amounts can cause discomfort for sensitive individuals.”
— Dr. Susan Warner, seafood safety specialist
Safe Consumption Guidelines
- Portion Size: Experts generally advise eating no more than 2–3 ounces at a time.
- Frequency: Rare or occasional indulgence is advised rather than making it a sushi staple.
- Labeling Checks: Always ask your sushi chef if “white tuna” or “butterfish” is escolar.
Escolar in the Sushi Industry: Trends and Controversy
Over the past decade, DNA testing by groups like Oceana has uncovered extensive seafood mislabeling in restaurants across North America and Europe. Escolar routinely appears at the center of these scandals, substituted for more expensive white fish or tuna.
Regulatory and Consumer Responses
Japanese regulators have taken a notably strict stance—since 1977, escolar has been banned from sale in Japan due to safety concerns. In contrast, U.S. regulations focus on transparency, requiring that fish be labeled accurately. However, enforcement in the restaurant industry remains inconsistent, with consumers often left to inquire about the origin and type of their sushi.
Restaurants operating responsibly now openly list escolar by its correct name and advise customers about potential digestive effects. Some even avoid serving it altogether to protect their brand reputation.
Case Study: Sushi Bar Transparency
At a prominent New York City sushi bar in 2019, diners noticed new menu notations identifying escolar as “Escolar (Butterfish)—Please enjoy in small portions.” The chef, who had previously listed it as “white tuna,” reported an increase in customer questions and a modest uptick in customer trust.
This shift reflects a growing awareness among diners to scrutinize seafood sources, as well as a trend toward ethical transparency within the modern sushi industry.
Key Takeaways and Considerations
Escolar brings a unique, creamy bite to the sushi experience but is not without risks. The combination of delicious flavor, confusing labeling, and potential for digestive upset makes it both a delicacy and a dilemma.
Sushi lovers are encouraged to:
- Ask questions when “white tuna,” “butterfish,” or unfamiliar white fish are on the menu.
- Enjoy escolar in moderation, adhering to recommended serving sizes.
- Value restaurants that practice honest, transparent labeling and are upfront about their sourcing.
As seafood traceability technology improves, diners can expect more clarity—but personal vigilance remains the best defense against unwanted surprises at the sushi bar.
FAQs
What is escolar in sushi?
Escolar is a deep-sea fish served at some sushi restaurants, prized for its buttery texture and mild flavor. It is not true tuna, though it is often mistakenly marketed as “white tuna.”
Why is escolar sometimes called “butterfish” or “white tuna”?
Names like “butterfish” and “white tuna” are used for marketing purposes because of escolar’s appealing texture and appearance. However, this labeling can be misleading and may not reflect the fish’s true identity.
Is eating escolar safe?
Eating small amounts of escolar is generally safe for most people, but consuming larger portions can cause digestive discomfort due to wax esters present in its flesh. Some countries have restricted or banned escolar for this reason.
How can I identify escolar at a sushi bar?
Look for menu listings clearly naming escolar, and be cautious if “white tuna” is offered—it’s often a euphemism for escolar. When in doubt, ask the sushi chef for clarification.
Why do some countries ban escolar?
Escolar has been banned in countries such as Japan because of its high wax ester content, which can lead to unpleasant digestive effects. These bans are intended to protect consumers from accidental overconsumption.
Can I eat escolar if I have a sensitive stomach?
Individuals with digestive sensitivities should be especially careful, limiting or avoiding escolar altogether. If you choose to try it, stick to very small servings and pay attention to your body’s reaction.
